Barnabas

Robert A. Kraft

This material derives from Volume 3 of The Apostolic Fathers: A New Translation and Commentary, edited by Robert M. Grant (New York: Thomas Nelson and Sons, 1965), copyright by Robert A. Kraft [reassigned from publisher 1991], edited for electronic use with the help of Jay C. Treat (1993) and Monica Park (2002), with subsequent updates by RAK.

This version, without commentary, was prepared for the Early Christian Sources project (http://early.xpian.info) in 2021 with the author’s permission to distribute this online. The full version with commentary is available at http://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/rak/publics/barn/barndidintro.htm.

Introduction (1.1-2.3)

Salutation (1.1)

1.1. Greetings, sons and daughters, in the Name of the Lord1 who loved us, in peace. {page 81}

Commendation (1.2-3)

2. Seeing that God’s righteous acts toward you are so extraordinary and abundant, my joy over your favored and illustrious spirits is unbounded—you have received such grace, such an implantation of the pneumatic gift! 3. Wherefore I, who also hope to be saved, inwardly rejoice all the more because I can actually see that the spirit which is on you has been poured out in your midst from the abundance of the fountain2 of the Lord [see 11.2]. My eagerly anticipated visit to you has so wonderfully exceeded all expectations concerning you!

Purpose and themes (1.4-8)

4. Therefore, I am convinced of this—indeed, I am all the more conscious of it because I know that he who spoke3 many things in your midst was my traveling companion in the Way of Righteousness, the Lord;4 and for this reason I myself am constrained at all times to love you more than my own soul— {page 82} for great faith and love dwell in you, with hope of obtaining the life he gives! 5. Therefore, since it has occurred to me that if I am diligent in imparting to you a measure of what I have received it will be to my credit for having ministered to such spirits, I have hastened to send you this brief communication so that along with your faith you might also have perfect gnosis.

6. There are, then, three basic doctrines of the Lord of life:5 Hope, the beginning and end of our faith; and Righteousness, the beginning and end of judgment; (and) Love, a witness of the joy and gladness6 of works done in righteousness.

7. For the Master has made known to us through the prophets what already has come to pass and what is now occurring, and he has given us a foretaste of what is about to happen. Thus as we observe each of these things being worked out as he said, we ought all the more abundantly {page 83} and enthusiastically draw near in fear of him7. 8. And now, not as a Teacher but as one from your very midst, I will point out a few things which will enable you to rejoice in the present circumstances.

Transition to the first main section (2.1-3)

2.1. Since, then the present days are evil and he who is now at work possesses the power, we ought to walk circumspectly and seek out the Lord’s righteous requirements. 2. The auxiliaries of our faith, then, are Fear and Endurance, while Patience and Self-control also fight along at our side. 3. Thus while these allies remain in a pure state [see 19.8c] in relation to the Lord, there rejoice with them Wisdom, Understanding, Knowledge, and Gnosis. {page 84}

I. What The Lord Requires (2.4-3.6)

4. For he made it clear to us through all the prophets that he needs neither sacrifices nor whole burnt offerings nor offerings in general—as he says in one place:

5. What good is the multitude of your sacrifices to me? says the Lord. I am satiated with burnt offerings of rams and the fat of lambs, and I do not want the blood of bulls and goats—not even if you come and appear before me! For who has required these things from your hands? Do not continue to tread my (Temple) court. If you bring finely ground flour, it is vain; offering of incense is an abomination to me, I cannot bear your new moon festivals and sabbaths [see 15.8; Isa. 1.11-13].

{page 85}

6. Therefore he set these things aside [9.4b; 16.2], so that the new law of our Lord Jesus Christ, which is not tied to a yoke of necessity [cf. Acts 15.10], might have its own offering which is not man-made [see 16.7b].

7. And again he says to them:

Did I command your fathers, when they were coming out of the land of Egypt, to offer burnt offerings and sacrifices to me? 8. But, rather, this is what I commanded them [see Jer. 7.22 f.]—Let none of you hold a grudge in his heart against his neighbor, and love not a false oath [see Zech. 7.9 f. = 8.16 f.].

9. Therefore, since we are not without understanding, we ought to perceive the gracious intention of our Father. For he is speakingto us, desiring that we who are not misled as they were should seek how we might approach him with our offering. {page 86}

10a. To us, then, he speaks thus:8

A sacrifice to God is a broken heart [see Ps. 51.17]; An odor well pleasing to the Lord is a heart which glorifies its creator.

10b. Therefore, brethren, we ought to pay strict attention to the matters which concern our salvation, lest the Wicked One causes error [4.1; 12.10; 14.5] to slip in among us and hurls us away from our life!

3.1. Therefore he speaks again concerning these things to them:

Why do you make a fast to me, says the Lord, so that today your voice is heard wailing? This is not the sort of fast I have chosen, says the Lord, not a man humiliating his soul.9 2. Not even if you bend your neck in the shape of a circle, and deck yourselves out in10 sackcloth and ashes—you cannot even call such conduct an acceptable fast! [Isa. 58.4b-5.]

3. But to us he says:

Behold, this is the fast which I have chosen, says the Lord.11 Loose every bond of injustice, untie the knots of forcibly extracted agreements. {page 87} Release the downtrodden with forgiveness, and tear up every unjust contract. Distribute your food to the hungry, and12 if you see someone naked, clothe him. Bring the homeless into your home, and if you see someone of lowly estate, do not despise him, nor (despise) anyone of your own household.13 4. Then your light will break forth early, and your healing14 will arise quickly. And your righteousness will go before you, and the glory of God will surround you. 5. Then you will cry out, and God will listen to you; While you are still speaking, he will say “Here I am”— if you put away from you bonds and scornful gestures and words of complaint, and give your food to the hungry without hypocrisy, and have mercy on15 the person of lowly estate [Isa.58. 6-10a].

6. For this reason, therefore, brethren, when he foresaw how the people whom he prepared in his Beloved One would believe in childlike innocence [see 6.11], the Patient One gave us a preview concerning everything [2.4], lest we be shattered to pieces as “proselytes” to their law.

{page 88}

II. Readiness in the Shadow of Crisis (4.1-14)

Transition to the new section (4.1-2)

4.1a. We must, then, carefully investigate the present situation [cf. 17.2] and seek out the things which are able to save us.

1b. Therefore let us completely flee from all the works of lawlessness, lest the works of lawlessness ensnare us [5.4]; And let us hate the error of the present age [4.10a], so that we might be loved in the age to come.

2. Let us give no leisure to our own soul so that it has opportunity to associate with the wicked and sinful—lest we become like them! [Cf. 10.3-8.]

The imminent eschatological crisis (4.3-6a)

3a. The great final scandal is at hand, concerning which it has been written—as Enoch16 says. 3b. For the Master cut short the times and the days [see 15.5] for this reason, that his Beloved {page 89} One might hasten and come into his inheritance. 4. And the prophet speaks thus:17

Ten kingdoms18 will reign on the earth. And afterward there will arise a little king, who will humiliate three of the kingdoms19 simultaneously.

5. Similarly, Daniel says concerning the same one:

And I saw the fourth beast, wicked and powerful and more dangerous than all the beasts of the sea;20 And how that ten horns sprouted from him, and from them budded a little offshoot of a horn; And how that it humiliated three of the great horns simultaneously.

6a. Therefore you ought to understand! [cf. Mark 13.14.]

Danger of misplaced security in the covenant (4.6b-8)

6b. Furthermore, I also urge you [21.2, 4, 8] as one of your own, and especially as one who loves you all more than I love my own self, walk circumspectly21 and do not be like certain people [4.2], compounding your sins {page 90} by claiming that your covenant is irrevocably yours.22 6c. But they lost it completely in the following manner, after Moses already had received it—7. for the scripture says:

And Moses was on the mountain fasting for forty days and forty nights, and he received the covenant from the Lord, stone tablets inscribed by the finger of the Lord’s hand.

But when they turned to idols, they lost it. 8a. For the Lord speaks thus:

Moses, Moses, descend immediately, for your people whom you led out from the land of Egypt have sinned.

And Moses understood, and he hurled the two tablets from his hands. 8b. And the covenant (of the tablets) was smashed to bits so that the covenant of Jesus, the Beloved One, might be sealed in our heart, in hope of his faith.

Parenthetical personal note (4.9a)

9a. But since I wish to write many things—not as a Teacher would, but as is fitting for a friend to do—and to omit nothing of what we have received [see 17.1], I hurry along. I am your devoted slave. {page 91}

Warnings against overconfidence (4.9b-14)

9b. Wherefore let us walk circumspectly in these last days. For the entire period of our life and faith23 will be wasted unless now, in the lawless time and in the impending scandals, we resist as befits God’s sons. 10a. Therefore,24 lest the Black One make deceitful entrance [2.10b], let us flee from all that is irrelevant, let us hate completely [4.1b] the works of the wicked way. 10b. Do not live monastic lives by retiring to yourselves as though you have already attained the righteous state, but by assembling together, seek out together what is to your mutual advantage. 11a. For the scripture says:

Woe to those who are wise in their own eyes, and understanding in their own sight [Isa. 5.21]. {page 92}

11b. Let us be pneumatics; let us be a perfect Temple to God. To the best of our ability let us meditate on the fear of God and strive to keep his commandments, so that we might rejoice in his ordinances. 12. The Lord will judge the world impartially. Each man will receive payment in accord with his deeds—if he was good, his righteousness precedes him; if he was wicked, the reward of wickedness goes before him! 13. Thus on no account should we slumber in our sins [4.2; cf. 4.6b] by relaxing as “those who have been called”—and the wicked Archon will take advantage of his power over us [2.1] and push us away from the kingdom of the Lord [2.10b]. 14. And finally, my brethren, understand this: When you notice what great signs and wonders were performed in Israel [5.8] and still they have been abandoned, let us take heed lest we be found to be, as it is written, “many called but few chosen” [see Matt. 22.14].

III. Why the Lord Endured Suffering (5.1-8.7)

The Lord endured fleshly suffering to purify us (5.1-2)

5.1. For it was for this reason that the Lord submitted to deliver his flesh to destruction, that by the forgiveness of sins we might be purified [8.1]—that is, by the sprinkling (for purification) of his {page 93} blood.25 2. For it is written concerning him—partly with reference to Israel [6.7b] and partly to us—and it says thus:

He was wounded because of our lawless actions, and he was rendered helpless because of our sins; by his wounds we were healed [Isa. 53.5]. As a sheep to the slaughter was he led, and as a lamb he was silent before his shearer [Isa. 53.7b].

Parenthetical admonition to exercise gnosis (5.3-4)

3. We ought, therefore, to give heartfelt thanks to the Lord because he has both given us gnosis of the things which have come to pass, and has given us wisdom in the present events—nor are we without understanding concerning what is about to happen [1.7; 17.1 f.]. 4a. But the scripture says:

It is not unjust to spread out nets for capturing birds [Prov. 1.17].

4b. This is what it is saying: It is just that a man should perish if, although he has gnosis of the Way of Righteousness, he becomes ensnared in the Way of Darkness [see 4.1 f., 9b ff.).

The Lord endured to fulfill the promise(s) (5.5-7)

5. And furthermore, my brethren, consider this: if the Lord submitted to suffer for our souls—he who is Lord of the {page 94} whole world, to whom God said at the foundation of the world:

Let us make man in accord with our image and likeness [Gen. 1.26a]—

then how is it that he submitted to suffer at the hand of men? [Cf. 7.2.] Learn! 6. The prophets, after they had received special insight from him, prophesied concerning him. And he submitted so that he might break the power of Death and demonstrate the resurrection from the dead—thus it was necessary for him to be manifested in flesh. 7. Also (he submitted) so that he might fulfill the promise to the fathers [14.1] and, while he was preparing26 the new people for himself and while he was still on earth, to prove that after he has brought about the resurrection he will judge.

The Lord endured in flesh so that sinners could see him (5.8-10)

8. Furthermore, although he was teaching Israel and doing such great wonders and signs [4.14], the result was not that they loved him dearly for his preaching!27 9. But when he chose his {page 95} own apostles who were destined to preach his gospel [8.3]—men who were sinful beyond measure so that he might prove that he came not to call righteous but sinners28 [Mark 2.17b parr.]—it was then that he revealed himself as God’s Son [12.10]. 10. For if he had not come in flesh, how could men be saved by looking at him?29 They cannot even gaze directly into the rays of the sun, even though it is a work of his hands and is destined to cease existing! [15.5.]

The Lord endured to complete the number of Israel’s sins (5.11-14)

11. Thus the Son of God came in flesh for this reason, that he might bring to summation the total of sins [8.1-2; 14.5] of those who persecuted his prophets to death. 12a. So also he submitted for this reason. 12b. For God says that the afflicting of his flesh [7.2] came from them: {page 96}

When they smite their own Shepherd, then the sheep of the flock will be lost30 [see Zech. 13.7].

13a. And he desired to suffer in such a manner, for it was necessary so that he might suffer on the wood [7.5; 8.5; 12.1, 5]. 13b. For one who prophesies concerning him says:

Spare my soul from the sword [Ps. 22.20a] and affix my flesh with nails [see Ps. 119.120a (but in LXX/OG text form)], for a synagogue31 of wicked men have come upon me32 [see Ps. 22.16b].

14. And again he says:

Behold, I have bared my back for stripes, and my cheeks for smiting [Isa. 50.6a], but I have set my face as a solid rock [Isa. 50.7b].

Vindication of the Lord who endured (6.1-4)

6.1. When, therefore, he made the commandment, what does he say?

Who disputes my judgment? Let him oppose me. Or who vindicates himself in my presence? Let him draw near to the Lord’s Servant. 2a. Woe to you, for you all will grow old like a garment, and a moth will devour you! [Isa. 50.8b-9.] {page 97}

2b. And again, since he was established as a mighty Stone which crushes, the prophet says of him:

Behold, I will insert into the foundations of Zion a Stone which is precious, chosen, a cornerstone, prized [Isa. 28.16a].

3a. Then what does he say?

And whoever trusts in him33 will live forever [8.5b; 11.10 f.].

3b. Is our hope, then, on a stone? Not in the least! But he speaks in such a way since the Lord has established his flesh in strength. 3c. For he says:

And he established me as a solid Rock [see Isa. 50.7b].

4a. And again the prophet says:

The very Stone which the builders rejected has become the cornerstone! [Ps. 118.22.]

4b. And again he says:

This is the great and awesome Day which the Lord made [Ps. 118.24a (see 118.23)].

Summary statement about the Lord’s suffering (6.5-7)

5. I write to you more clearly so that you might understand. I am a slave devoted to your love [4.9a].

6. What, then, does the prophet say again?

A synagogue of wicked men encompasses me [Ps. 22.16b], they surround me as bees around honey [Ps. 118.12a], and for my garments they cast lots [Ps. 22.18b].

7a. Thus, since he was about to be manifested in flesh and to suffer [12.2a], his passion was revealed beforehand. 7b. For the prophet says concerning Israel [5.2]:

Woe to them, for they devised a wicked plot against themselves when they said, “Let us bind the Righteous One, for he is displeasing to us” [Isa. 3.9b-10a; see Wisd. Sol. 2.12]. {page 98}

The good land of the new creation (6.8-19)

8. What does the other prophet, Moses, say to them?34

Behold, thus says the Lord God: Enter into the good land, which the Lord promised [5.7] to Abraham and Isaac and Jacob, and make it your inheritance—a land flowing milk and honey [see Exod. 33.1, 3; Deut. 6.18, etc.]. {page 99}

9. And what does “gnosis” say? Learn!

Hope, it says, on that Jesus who is about to appear to you in flesh [5.1]. For man is land suffering, for Adam was formed [6.11-14] from the face of the land.

10a. What, then, does he say? “Into the good land—a land flowing milk and honey” [6.8].

10b. Blessed be our Lord, brethren, who has placed in us wisdom and understanding of his secrets. For the prophet says:

Who can understand a parable of the Lord35, except he who is wise and understanding, and who loves his Lord?

11. Since, then, he renovated us by the forgiveness of sins, he made us to be another sort (of creation), as though {page 100} we had a child’s soul [cf. 3.6]—he fashioned us again [cf. 6.9b], as it were. 12a. For the scripture is speaking about us when he says to the Son [5.5]:

Let us make man in accord with our image and likeness, and let them rule over the beasts of the earth and the birds of heaven and the fish of the sea [Gen. 1.26].

12b. And when he saw how well we were formed [6.9b], the Lord said:

Increase and multiply and fill the earth [Gen. 1.28].

These things (he said) to the Son.36

13a. Again, I will show you how he says to us that he made a second fashioning in the last times. 13b. And the Lord says:

Behold, I make the last things like the first.

13c. It is for this reason, therefore, that the prophet proclaimed: “Enter into the land flowing milk and honey, and exercise lordship over it” [see 6.8]. 14a. See, then, we have been fashioned anew! 14b. As he says again in another prophet:

Behold, says the Lord, I will remove from them— that is, from those on whom he foresaw the Lord’s spirit37— their stony hearts, and I will insert fleshly hearts.

14c. Because he was about to be manifested in flesh [5.1] and to dwell in us. 15. For, my brethren, our heart being thus inhabited constitutes a holy Temple to the Lord! [16.6-10.] 16a. for the Lord says again:

And in what manner shall I appear before the Lord my God and be glorified? [see Ps. 42.2b]

16b. He says:

I will confess you in the assembly38 of my brethren, and I will praise you in the midst of the assembly39 of saints [Ps. 22.22].

16c. Therefore we are those whom he conducts into the good land!

17a. What, then, is the “milk and honey”? Because the infant is {page 101} initiated into life first by honey, then by milk. 17b. Thus also, in a similar way, when we have been initiated into life by faith in the promise [6.8, 14.1b] and by the word, we will live exercising lordship over the land. 18a. But as it was already said above [see 6.12]: “And they shall increase, and multiply, and rule over the fish….” 18b. Who, then, is presently able to rule over beasts or fish or birds of heaven? [Cf. 10.3-5, 10.] For we ought to understand that “to rule” implies that one is in control [see 2.1], so that he who gives the orders exercises dominion. 19. If, then, this is not the present situation, he has told us when it will be—when we ourselves have been perfected as heirs of the Lord’s covenant [14.5].

Transition back to the main theme of suffering (7.1-2)

7.1. Understand, therefore, children of joy,40 that the good Lord revealed everything to us beforehand so that we might know whom we ought to praise continually with thanksgiving. {page 102}

2. If, then, the Son of God, who is Lord and is about to judge the living and dead, suffered so that his being afflicted [5.2, 12b] might bring us life [12.5], let us believe that it was not possible for the Son of God to suffer except on our behalf.

Lessons from the Atonement ritual: the Fast and the scapegoat (7.3-11)

3a. But he also drank vinegar and gall [see Ps. 69.21] when he was crucified. 3b. Hear how the priests of the Temple made even this clear, when the commandment was written:

Whoever does not fast during the (Atonement) Fast must surely die [see Lev. 23.29].

3c. The Lord gave such a commandment since he was destined to offer the vessel of the spirit as a sacrifice for our sins, so that the “type” which is based on Isaac’s having been offered up on the altar [Gen. 22.9] also might be fulfilled. 4. What, then, does he say in the prophet?

And they shall eat from the goat which is offered up during the Fast for all sins [cf. Lev. 16.9, 27]—

pay attention more diligently—

and the priests alone shall all eat the entrails unwashed, with vinegar. {page 103}

5. For what reason?

Since I am destined to offer my flesh [5.1] for the sins of my new people, you (priests) are about to drink gall mixed with vinegar—you alone will eat while the people fast and smite themselves on sackcloth and ashes.

This is to demonstrate that he must suffer at their hands41 [5.11 ff.; 12.5].

6. Pay attention to what he commanded:

Take two goats which are handsome and alike, and present them; and let the priest take one for a burnt offering for sins [Lev. 16.7, 9].

7a. But what do they do with the other?

Accursed, he says, is the other [see Lev. 16.8].

7b. Pay attention to how the type of Jesus is made clear!

8a. And you shall all spit on and prick (that goat), and encircle its head with scarlet wool, and thus let it be cast out into the desert [see Lev. 16.10].

8b. And when this has been done, the one who bears the goat brings (it) into the desert42 and takes the wool and places it upon a bush which is called ραχης (raches),43 the buds of which we are {page 104} accustomed to eat when we find them in the countryside. Thus of the ραχης (raches) alone are the fruits sweet.

9a. What, then, does it mean—pay attention—that the one is placed on the altar [7.6] and the other is accursed [7.7a], and that the accursed one is crowned? [7.8a.] 9b. Because they will see him then, on that day, wearing the scarlet robe around his flesh [5.1], and they will say:

Is not this he whom we once crucified, despising and piercing and spitting on him? [7.8a.] Surely this was the one who then said he was God’s Son! [See Mark 15.39b, parr.]

10a. Now how is this like that situation? For this reason the goats were alike and handsome [7.6], equal, so that when they see it coming then [7.8b, 9b], they will be amazed at the similarity of the goat. 10b. Therefore notice here the type of Jesus who was destined to suffer.

11a. And what does it mean that they place the wool in the midst of the thorns? [7.8b.] It is a type of Jesus placed in the church, so that whoever desires to snatch away the scarlet wool must suffer many things because the thornbush is treacherous, and he must obtain it through affliction. {page 105} 11b. In such a way, he says, those who desire to see me and to take hold of my kingdom [8.5] ought to take me through affliction and suffering [see Acts 14.22].

Lessons from the red heifer ritual (8.1-7) [see Num. 19.1-10]

8.1. And what do you suppose is the type involved here, in that he commanded to Israel that those men in whom sins are complete should offer a heifer; and when they had slaughtered it, to burn it; and then the children should take the ashes and put them into a container; and the scarlet wool should be wrapped around a piece of wood—again, note the type of the cross [see 12.1-7], and the scarlet wool [7.8-11] and the hyssop; and thus the children sprinkle the people individually in order to purify them from sins? [5.1.] 2. Understand how it is told to you in such simplicity: the calf is Jesus; the sinful men who offer it are those who offered him to be slaughtered [5.2]. Then men (appear) no longer, (it is) no longer (concerned with) the “glory” of sinners! [Cf. 5.11.] 3a. Those who sprinkle are children [cf. 6.11], they are those who preach to us forgiveness of sins and purification of the heart,44 to whom he entrusted the authority to proclaim the gospel [5.9]. 3b. There are twelve (of the latter), for a witness to the tribes, since there are twelve tribes of Israel. 4. But why are there (only) three children who sprinkle? This is for a witness to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, because they are great before God.

5. And the fact that the wool is on the wood [8.1] signifies that the kingdom of Jesus [7.11b] is on the wood, and that those who hope on him will live forever [6.3a]. 6. But why are the wool and the hyssop together? Because in his kingdom there shall be wicked and vile days, in which we shall be saved. For the one whose flesh is distressed is cured by means of the hyssop’s vileness!

7. Wherefore, the things which have come to pass [1.7] are clear to us, but hidden to them, because they did not hearken to the Lord’s voice. {page 106}

IV. Concerning Circumcised Understanding (9.1-10.12)

Exhortations to “hear” (9.1-4a)

9.1a. For again, he speaks concerning the ears, how he circumcised the ears of45 our heart. 1b. The Lord says in the prophet:

By listening with the ear, they hearkened to me [Ps. 18.44a].

1c. And again he says:

By hearing, those who are far off shall hearken; The things I have done will become known [Isa. 33.13]. And circumcise, says the Lord, your hearts46 [cf. Deut.10.16; Jer.4.4].

2. And again he says:

Hear, Israel, for thus says the Lord your God [see Jewish scriptures passim];47 Who is he who desires to live forever? [See Ps. 34.12a.] By hearing, let him hearken to the voice of my servant [see Isa. 50. 10a]. {page 107}

3a. And again he says:

Hear, heaven, and give ear, earth; for the Lord has spoken [Isa. 1.2a]—

these are mentioned as a witness [cf. Deut. 4.26]. 3b. And again he says:

Hear the Lord’s word, rulers of this people [Isa. 28.14; 1.10].

3c. And again he says:

Hear, children, a voice crying in the desert [Isa. 40.3].

3d. Therefore he circumcised our ears, so that when we hear the word, we might believe.

False and true circumcision (9.4b-5)

4a. But he also set aside [2.6; 16.2] the circumcision on which they relied. 4b. For he said that circumcision was not a matter of the flesh, but they became transgressors [5.11] because a wicked angel [18.1] “enlightened” them. 5a. And he says to them:

Thus says the Lord your God—

here I find a commandment—

Woe48 to those who sow among thorns; Be circumcised to your Lord [Jer. 4.3-4]. {page 108}

5b. And what is he saying?

Circumcise the wickedness from your heart!49

5c. And again he says:50

Behold, the Lord says, all the nations have uncircumcised foreskins, but this people is uncircumcised in heart! [See Jer. 9.26.]

The meaning of Abraham’s circumcision (9.6-9)

6. But you will say: And yet the people received circumcision as a special sign [Gen. 17.11]. But every Syrian and Arab, and all the priests of the idols also (are circumcised). Are they also, then, from their covenant? But even the Egyptians are in circumcision! [See Jer. 9.25 f.]

7. Learn, then, abundantly concerning everything, children of love [7.1; 21.9]; for when Abraham first gave circumcision, he circumcised while looking forward in the spirit to Jesus, and he received the teachings of the three letters. 8a. For it says:

And Abraham circumcised the men of his household [Gen. 17.23], 18 and 300 (in number) [Gen. 14.14]. {page 109}

8b. What, then, is the gnosis which was given him? (See 19.1c.) Learn! [9.7.] For a distinction is made in that the 18 comes first, then it says 300. Now the (number) 18 (is represented by two letters), J = 10 and E = 8—thus you have “JE,” (the abbreviation for) “JEsus.”51 And because the cross, represented by the letter T (= 300), was destined to convey special significance, it also says 300. He makes clear, then, that JEsus is symbolized by the two letters (JE = 18), while in the one letter (T = 300) is symbolized the cross.

9. He who placed the implanted gift of his teaching52 in us knows! No one has learned From me a more trustworthy lesson! But I know that you are worthy [cf. 14.1b,4a].

The intention of Mosaic food restrictions (10.1-2)

10.1. Now when Moses said:

Eat neither pig [10.3], nor eagle nor hawk nor crow [10.4], nor any fish which is without scales [10.5; see Lev. 11.7-15; Deut. 14.8-14],

he received in his understanding three doctrines. 2a. Further, he says to them in Deuteronomy: {page 110}

And I will ordain as a covenant [14.5b] for this people my righteous ordinances [see Deut. 4.10, 13].

2b. Therefore it is not God’s commandment that they (literally) should not eat, but Moses spoke in the spirit.

The three doctrines of Moses (10.3-5) [tradition 1, see 10.1]

3a. For this reason, then, he mentions the “pig”: Do not associate, he is saying, with such men—men who are like pigs. That is, men who forget their Lord when they are well off, but when they are in need, they acknowledge the Lord; 3b. just as when the pig is feeding it ignores its keeper, but when it is hungry it makes a din, and after it partakes it is quiet again [10.10c].

4a. “Neither eat the eagle nor the hawk nor the kite nor the crow.” Do not, he is saying, associate with nor be like such men—men who do not know how to procure their own food by honest labor and sweat, but in their lawlessness they plunder the possessions of others, and they keep sharp watch as they walk around in apparent innocence, and spy out whom they might despoil by plundering; 4b. just as those birds are unique in not procuring their own food, but as they perch idly by, they seek how they might devour the flesh of others-pestilent creatures in their wickedness! [10.10d.] {page 111}

5a. “And do not eat,” he says, “sea eel nor octopus nor cuttlefish.” Do not, he is saying, be like53 such men—men who are completely impious and have already been condemned to death [see 11.7*]; 5b. just as those fish are uniquely cursed and loiter in the depths, not swimming about as do the rest but inhabiting the murky region beneath the deep water [10.10b].

The three doctrines on sexual sins (10.6-8) [tradition 2]

6a. But neither shall you eat the hairy-footed animal [Lev. 11.5; Deut. 14.7]. Why not? Do not be, he is saying, one who corrupts children, nor be like such people; 6b. because the hare increases unduly its discharge each year, and thus has as many holes as it is years old.54 {page 112}

7a. But neither shall you eat the hyena [cf. Jer. 12.9 LXX/OG]. Do not, he is saying, be an adulterer nor a corrupter,55 nor be like such people. 7b. Why? Because this animal changes its nature each year, and at one time it is male while at another it is female.

8a. But also he hated the weasel [see Lev. 11.29], fittingly. Do not, he is saying, be such a person. We hear of such men, who perform a lawless deed uncleanly with the mouth. Neither associate with those unclean women who perform the lawless deed with the mouth.56 8b. For this animal conceives through its mouth.

Summary and support from David (10.9-10d)

9. Concerning foods, then, when Moses received the three doctrines [10.1] he spoke out thus, in the spirit [10.2b]. But because of fleshly desires they accepted his words as though they concerned actual food [10.2b; cf. 9.4b]. {page 113}

10a. And David also received gnosis of the same three doctrines [10.1]—and he says [Ps. 1.1]:

10b. Blessed is the man who has not walked according to the counsel of impious men—

just as the fish which grope in darkness in the depths [10.5b]—

10c. nor stood in the way of sinners—

just as those who appear to fear the Lord sin like the pig [10.3]—

10d. nor sat in the seat of pestilent fellows—

just like the birds perched for plundering [10.4b].

Moses’ positive food laws, conclusion (10.10e-12)

10e. Now receive complete (understanding) concerning food.57 11a. Moses says again:

Eat every split-hooved and cud-chewing animal [Lev. 11.3; Deut. 14.6].

11b. What is he saying (about the latter)? That (the animal) which receives fodder knows who feeds it, and while it relies on him, it seems content [cf. 10.3, 10c]. He spoke fittingly in view of the commandment. 11c. What, then is he saying? Associate with those who fear the Lord, with those who meditate in their heart on the subtleties of the matter, {page 114} with those who proclaim the Lord’s righteous ordinances and keep them, with those who realize that study is a joyful occupation, and who “ruminate” on the Lord’s word. 11d. And what does the “split-hooved” mean? That the righteous man both walks in this world and anticipates the holy aeon.

11e. See how appropriately Moses legislated! 12a. But how could they perceive or understand these things? [See 9.4b.] But since we rightly understand the commandments, we are speaking as the Lord desired. 12b. This is why he circumcised our ears and hearts [9.1, 4a], so that we might understand these things.

V. Baptism and the Cross Foreshadowed (11.1-12.11)

Transition to the new section (11.1a)

11.1a. But let us investigate whether the Lord was concerned to reveal beforehand concerning the water and concerning the cross.

Concerning the water (11.1b-5)

1b. First, concerning the water, it is written with reference to Israel how they never will accept the baptism which conveys forgiveness of sins, but they will build (cisterns) for themselves. 2. For the prophet says: {page 115}

Be astounded, Heaven, and shudder greatly at this, Earth, For this people has committed two wicked acts— They have forsaken me, the living fount [see 1.3] of water,58 And they have dug out for themselves a pit of death59 [Jer. 2.12-13]. 3. Has my holy mount Sinai become an arid rock? For you shall be as the fledglings of a bird, fluttering about when they are taken from the nest60 [Isa. 16.1b-2].

4. And again the prophet says:

I will go before you, and I will level mountains and shatter gates of brass and break iron bars, And I will give you treasures—dark, hidden, unseen— that they might know that I am the Lord God [Isa. 45.2-3a]. 5. And you will dwell in an elevated cave made from solid rock, and61 its water supply is dependable. You will see a king in his glory, and your soul will meditate on the fear of the Lord [Isa. 33.16-18]. {page 116}

Concerning water and wood together (11.6-11)

6. And again he says in another prophet:

And he who does these things will be like the tree planted by springs of waters, which produces its fruit at the proper time, and which has leaves that will not wither; And everything he does will prosper. 7. The impious are not like this—not in the least. But rather, they are like the dust which the wind drives from the face of the earth. For this reason, the impious will not appear for judgment [see 10.5], nor sinners in the council of the Righteous. For the Lord knows the Way of the Righteous, and the Way of the Impious will perish [Ps. 1.3-6].

8a. Perceive how he referred to the water and the cross together.

8b. For this is what he is saying: “Blessed” [Ps. 1.1] are those who, having placed their hope in the cross [12.3], descend into the water. 8c. For the reward, he says, comes “at the proper time” {page 117} [11.6]—then, he says, I will repay. 8d. But as for the present, what does he say? “The leaves will not wither” [11.6]. He is saying this, that every word which flows forth from you—through your mouth [see 16.9]—in faith and love, will be a means of conversion and hope62 to many.

9. And again, another prophet says:

And the Land of Jacob was praised more than any land—

he is saying this, he glorifies63 the vessel of his spirit. 10. Then what does he say?

And there was a river flowing from the right side, and beautiful trees came up out of it. And whoever eats of them will live forever.

11a. He is saying this, that we go down into the water full of sins and vileness, and we come up bearing fruit in our heart, having in the spirit fear and hope in Jesus. 11b. “And whoever eats from these will live forever” [11.10]. He is saying this: Whoever, he says, hears these things which are spoken and believes will live forever [cf. 6.3a]. {page 118}

Concerning the cross (12.1-7)

12.1a. Similarly, he explains again concerning the cross in another prophet who says:

And when will these things come to pass, says the Lord?64 When a tree falls down and rises up, and when blood drips from a tree.

1b. Again, you have (information) concerning the cross and the one who was destined to be crucified [cf. 12.2a, 7d].

2a. And again he says in the (book of) Moses, when Israel was under attack from foreigners—and so that he might remind those who were being attacked that they had been given over to death because of their sins [see 12.5b]—the spirit says to Moses, in his heart, that he should make a type of the cross and of him who was destined to suffer [6.7; 12.1b]. 2b. If they do not, he is saying, place their hope on him, they will be under attack forever. 2c. Thus Moses piled one shield upon another in the midst of the battle, and as he stood elevated above them all he stretched out his hands. And as long as he did so, Israel again prevailed; but whenever he let (his hands) drop, they were again being killed [Exod. 17.8-15]. 3. Why? So that they might know that they could not be saved unless they hope on him [12.2b, 7b]. {page 119}

4. And again, in another prophet he says:

The whole day I have stretched out my hands to a people who are disobedient and who oppose my Righteous Way [Isa. 65.2; see Rom. 10.21].

5a. Again, Moses makes a type of Jesus—(signifying) that it was necessary for him to suffer [5.13a; 7.5] and that he whom they supposed had perished [see 7.9b] would bestow life [7.2; 12.7b]—in the standard65 (set up) when Israel was smitten (by a plague). 5b. For the Lord made every serpent to bite them, and they were dying, so that he might demonstrate to them that it was because of their transgression—since transgression took root in Eve because of the serpent [Gen. 3.1 ff.]—that they will be given over to mortal affliction [12.2a].

6a. Furthermore, it is this same Moses who commanded,

You shall have neither a cast-metal nor a carved image to your God [see Lev. 26.1; Deut. 27.15]—

he it is who makes (such an image) in order to provide a type of Jesus.

6b. Moses, then, makes a bronze serpent and sets it up in a prominent place and calls the people together by means of a {page 120} proclamation. 7a. Therefore, when they came together they begged Moses to offer a prayer on their behalf, that they might be healed. 7b. But Moses said to them:

Whenever, he says, anyone is bitten, let him come to the serpent which is erected on the wooden pole. And let him hope, believing that this dead object is able to bestow life [12.5a], and he will be healed immediately [12.3].

7c. And they did so [Num. 21.6-9].

7d. Again, you have also in these things the glory of Jesus [cf. 12.1b]—for all things take place in him and for his sake66 [cf. Rom. 11.36].

Whose Son is “Jesus”? (12.8-11)

8a. Again, what does Moses say to “Jesus” son of Naue, when he had given this name to him [Num. 13.8, 16] who was a prophet [Sirach 46.1; cf. Deut. 18.15] so that all the people might hearken {page 121} to him alone? 8b. For the Father is making all things clear concerning his Son “Jesus.” 9. Thus Moses says to “Jesus” son of Naue, to whom he had given this name when he sent him to spy out the land: Take a book in your hands and write what the Lord says, that “Jesus”67 the Son of God will cut off the entire house of Amalek by its roots at the end of days [see Exod. 17.14].

10a. Again, notice “Jesus”—not the son of a man68 but the Son of God, and manifested in flesh by a type.

10b. Since, then, they were going to say that Messiah is David’s Son, David himself—fearing and perceiving the error of the sinners [8.1]—prophesies:

The Lord said to my Lord, “Sit at my right hand until I make your enemies a footstool for your feet” [Ps. 110.1]. {page 122}

11a. And again, Isaiah says as follows:

The Lord said to my Messiah, the Lord,69 whose right hand I held, that nations would become obedient to him, and “I will demolish the strength of kings” [Isa. 45.1].

11b. Notice how David says he is “Lord,” and does not say “Son.”70

VI. The Covenant and its Recipients (13.1-14.9)

Transition to the new section (13.1)

13.1. But let us see if this people is the heir [13.6; 14.4 f.] or the former people, and if the covenant is for us or for them [4.6b]. {page 123}

The “Two People” (13.2-14.1a)

2. Therefore, hear what the scripture says concerning “the people”:

And Isaac was making entreaty for Rebecca his wife, because she was barren. And she became pregnant.71 Then Rebecca also went to inquire of the Lord, and the Lord said to her [see Gen. 25.21 f.]:

Two nations are in your womb, and two peoples in your belly. And one of the people will dominate the other, and the greater will be subject to the lesser [Gen. 25.23]. {page 124}

3. You ought to perceive who Isaac (represents) and who Rebecca, and with reference to whom he had pointed out that “this people” is “greater” than “that.”

4. And in another prophecy Jacob says it even more clearly to his son Joseph, when he says:

Behold, the Lord has not (yet) deprived me of your presence. Bring your sons to me, so that I might bless them [Gen. 48.11, 9b].

5a. And he brought Ephraim and Manasse near, intending that Manasse72 should receive the blessing since he was older—thus Joseph brought (the latter) to his father Jacob’s right hand [Gen. 48.13]. 5b. But Jacob saw, in the spirit, a type of “the people” which was to come afterward. 5c. And what does it say?

And Jacob crossed his hands and placed his right hand on the head of Ephraim,73 the second and younger (son), and blessed him [Gen. 48.14-15a]. And Joseph said to Jacob: “You should transpose your right hand to Manasse’s74 head, for he is my firstborn son.” And Jacob said to Joseph: “I know, child, I know, but the greater will be subject to the lesser” [see 13.2b].

And thus (Ephraim) received the blessing [Gen. 48.18-20]. 6. Take note on which of them he placed (his right hand)—this “people” is to be first, and heir of the covenant! [13.1.]

7a. Was, then, this situation also in view in the case of Abraham?75 We are receiving the perfection of our gnosis! [1.5] 7b. What, then, does he say to Abraham when for his belief alone he was established in righteousness? [see Gen. 15.6.]

Behold, I have established you, Abraham, as the father of nations which believe in God while uncircumcised [see Gen. 17.4-5; Rom. 4.11].

14.1a. Indeed, it was!76 {page 125}

The Covenant given and received (14.1b-9)

1b. But let us see if he has given the covenant which he promised the fathers [5.7] he would give to “the people.” 1c. He has given it, but they were not worthy to receive it because of their sins [14.5]. 2. For the prophet says:

And Moses was fasting on Mount Sinai, when he was to receive the Lord’s covenant with the people, for forty days and forty nights. And Moses received from the Lord the two tablets inscribed by the finger of the Lord’s hand, in the spirit. And when Moses received (them), he brought (them) down to give to the people. 3. And the Lord said to Moses:

Moses, Moses, descend immediately, because your people which you led out from the land of Egypt has sinned.

And Moses understood, for they had again made molten images for themselves, and he hurled the tablets from (his) hands, and the tablets of the Lord’s covenant were shattered [see 4.7-8].77

4a. Moses, then, received (it), but they did not prove worthy.

4b. And how did we receive it? Learn! Moses received it in the capacity of servant [see Exod. 14.31; Heb. 3.5]; {page 126} but the Lord himself gave it to us, to a “people” of inheritance, by submitting for us [5.1]. 5a. And he was made manifest so that they might fill up the measure of their sins [5.11], and we might receive it through Jesus, who inherits the Lord’s covenant78—5b. he was prepared for this reason, that by appearing himself and liberating from darkness our hearts which had already been paid over to death and given over to the lawlessness of error [16.7b], he might establish a covenant in us by a word. 6. For it is written how the Father commanded him to prepare a holy people for himself [5.7] when he had liberated us from the darkness. 7a. Therefore the prophet says:

I, the Lord your God, have called you in righteousness, and I will grasp your hand and empower you; And I have given you as a covenant to people, as a light for the nations, to open the eyes of the blind, and to release from their bonds those who have been shackled, and to lead out from their prison house those sitting in darkness [Isa. 42.6-7].

7b. Know79, then, whence we were liberated! 8. Again the prophet says:80

Behold, I have placed you as a light for the nations, that you might beam salvation to the end of the earth. Thus says the Lord God who liberated you [Isa. 49.6-7].

9. Again the prophet says:

The Lord’s spirit is on me, wherefore he anointed me to announce benefaction to the oppressed,81 he sent me to heal those who are broken hearted, to proclaim pardon to the captives and restoration of sight to the blind, to announce the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of recompense [see 21.1], to comfort all those who are in mourning [Isa. 61.1-2].82

{page 127}

VII. Concerning the Sabbath (15.1-9)

15.1. And furthermore, concerning the sabbath. It is written in the “Ten Words” by which (the Lord) spoke to Moses face to face [see Exod. 33.11; Deut. 5.4; 34.10] on Mount Sinai:

And you shall keep the Lord’s sabbath holy [see Exod. 20.8; Deut. 5.12; Jer. 17.22] with clean hands and a clean heart [see Ps. 24.4; 51.10].

2. And elsewhere he says:

If my sons guard the sabbath [see Exod. 31.16], then I will bestow my mercy on them [see Isa. 56.1-8].

3. He mentions “the sabbath” at the beginning of creation:

And God made the works of his hands in six days, and he finished on the seventh day. And he rested on it, and kept it holy [see Gen. 2.2-3].

{page 128}

4a. Pay attention, children, to what he says: “He finished in six days.” He is saying this, that in six thousand years the Lord will finish everything. For with him the “day” signifies a thousand years.83 4b. And he bears me witness (on this point) saying:

Behold, a day of the Lord84 shall be as a thousand years [cf. Ps. 90.4].

4c. Therefore, children, “in six days”—in six thousand years—“everything” will be “finished.”

5. “And he rested on the seventh day” [15.3b]. He is saying this: When his Son comes he will put an end to the time of the Lawless One,85 and judge the impious [cf. 10.5; 11.7], and change the sun [5.10] and moon and stars—then he will truly rest “on the seventh day.” {page 129}

6a. Furthermore he says: “Keep it holy with clean hands and a clean heart” [15.1b]. 6b. If, then, anyone at present is able, by being clean in heart,86 to keep holy the day which God hallowed, we have been deceived in everything! [Cf. 9.4b; 16.1.] 7. But if he keeps it holy87 at that time by truly resting [15.5b], when we ourselves are able (to do so) since we have been made righteous [cf. 4.10] and have received the promise [6.19]—when lawlessness is no more and all things have been made new by the Lord [6.13; 15.5]—at that time we will be able to keep it holy, when we ourselves first have been made holy!

8a. Further, he says to them [see 2.5b]:

I cannot bear your new moon celebrations and sabbaths [Isa. 1.13].

8b. See how he is saying that it is not your present sabbaths that are acceptable to me, but that (sabbath) which I have made, in which, when I have rested everything, I will make {page 130} the beginning of an eighth day—that is, the beginning of another world [see 6.13; 16.6c]. 9. Wherefore also we observe the eighth day as a time of rejoicing, for on it Jesus both arose from the dead and, when he had appeared, ascended into the heavens.

VIII. Concerning the Temple (16.1-10)

The old, physical Temple (16.1-5)

16.1. And finally, concerning the Temple. I will show you how those wretched men, when they went astray, placed their hope on the building and not on their God who created them—as though88 God has a house! 2a. For, roughly speaking, they consecrated him by means of the Temple, as the pagans do! 2b. But how does the Lord speak when he sets it aside? [2.6; 9.4b.] Learn!

Who measured the heaven with a span, or the earth with a hand? Was it not I, says the Lord? [Isa. 40.12.] {page 131} The heaven is my throne, and the earth is the stool for my feet. What sort of house will you erect for me, or what place for me to rest? [Isa. 66.1; see Acts 7.49.]

2c. You knew89 that their hope [16.1] was vain!

3. Furthermore, he says again:

Behold, those who tore down this Temple will themselves build it.

4. It is happening.90 For because of their fighting it was torn down by the enemies. And now the very91 servants of the enemies will themselves rebuild it.

5a. Again, it was made clear that the city and the Temple and the people of Israel were destined to be abandoned. 5b. For the scripture says [cf. 5.12b]:

And it shall be at the end of days that the Lord will abandon the sheep of the pasture, and the sheepfold, and their watchtower to destruction!

5c. And it happened just as the Lord announced!

The new, spiritual Temple (16.6-10)

6a. But let us inquire whether there is a Temple of God? There is, where he himself says he makes and prepares (it)! 6b. For it is written: {page 132}

And it shall come to pass when the “hebdomad” is finished, God’s Temple will be built gloriously in the Lord’s Name.

7a. Thus I find that there is a Temple.

7b. How, then, will it “be built in the Lord’s Name”? Learn! Before we believed in God the dwelling place of our heart was corrupt and infirm—truly a Temple built by human hands [see 2.6, Acts 7.48]. For it was full of idolatry, and was a house of demons, through doing whatever things were contrary to God. 8a. But “it will be built in the Lord’s Name”—pay attention92—so that the Temple of the Lord may be “built gloriously.” 8b. How? Learn! When we receive the forgiveness of sins and place our hope on the Name,93 we become new, created again from the beginning. Wherefore God truly dwells in our “dwelling place”—in us [6.15]. 9. In what way? The word of his faith, the invitation of his promise, the wisdom of his righteous ordinances, the commandments of his teaching [18.1a]; himself prophesying in us, himself dwelling in us—by opening for us the door of {page 133} the Temple, which is the mouth, and giving us repentance, he leads those who had been in bondage to death [14.5] into the incorruptible Temple. 10a. For he who longs to be saved looks not to the (external) man, but to him who dwells in him and speaks in him, and he is amazed at the fact that he never either had heard him speak such words from his mouth nor had himself ever desired to hear (them)! 10b. This is a pneumatic Temple built for the Lord!

Conclusion (17.1-2)

17.1. To the best of my ability, and in simplicity, (I have tried) to make (these things) clear to you—I hope that I have not neglected anything (vital).94 2a. For if I keep writing to you concerning things present or95 to come [1.5; 5.3], you would never comprehend because they are contained in parables. 2b. So much, on the one hand, for these matters.96

{page 134}

The Two Ways (18.1-21.9)

Introduction (18.1-2)

18.1a. But let us move on to another gnosis and teaching. 1b. There are two ways of teaching and authority: that of light and that of darkness. 1c. And there is a great difference between the two ways. 1d. For over one are appointed light-bearing angels of God, but over the other, angels of Satan. 2. And the former is Lord from everlasting to everlasting, but the latter is ruler of the present time of lawlessness. {page 137}

I. The Way of Light (19.1-12)

19.1a. Therefore, the Way of Light is this— 1b. if anyone who desires to traverse the way to the appointed place is diligent in his works. 1c. Therefore, the gnosis which is granted to us to walk in it is of this sort [see 9.8b]: 2a. You shall love him who made you; fear him who formed you;97 glorify him who redeemed you from death. {page 142} 2b. Be upright in heart [see Ps. 36.10] and rich in spirit [cf. Matt. 5.3!]. 2c. Do not associate with those who are proceeding98 in the way of death. 2d. Hate everything that is not pleasing to God. 2e. Hate all hypocrisy. 2f. Do not forsake the Lord’s commandments. 3a. Do not exalt yourself, but always be humble-minded. 3b. Do not allow yourself to become arrogant.99 3c. Do not take glory on yourself. 3d. Do not plot wickedly against your neighbor. 4a. Do not be sexually promiscuous. Do not commit adultery. Do not be sexually perverted. 4b. Let not the word of God depart from you with any sort of impurity [see 19.8c].100 4c. Do not show partiality in reproving anyone for transgressions. 4d. Be meek, be quiet, be one who fears the words which you have heard. 4e. Do not take the Lord’s name in vain.101 4f. Do not bear a grudge against your brother. 5a. Do not be undecided as to whether or not a thing shall come to pass. 5b. Love your neighbor more than yourself.102 5c. Do not murder a child by abortion, nor, again, destroy that which is born. 5d. Do not remove your control from your son or your daughter, but from youth up, teach the fear of the Lord. 6a. Be not desirous of the things of your neighbor.103 6b. Be not greedy, [=19.3a-b] neither be yoked from your soul with the haughty; but associate with the righteous and lowly. 6c. Whatever befalls you, receive these experiences as good, knowing that nothing happens without God.104 7a. Be not double-minded nor double-tongued105 for the double tongue is a snare of death.106 7b. Be subject to those over you as though to God, in reverence and fear. 7c. Do not give an angry command to your slave or maid-servant, who trust in the same God,107 lest they fear not the God who is over you both; Because he came not to call men according to status, but to call those in whom he prepared the spirit 8a. Share all things with your neighbor and do not claim that anything is exclusively yours; For if you are sharers in that which is imperishable, how much more so in what is perishable. 8b. Be not overtalkative, for the mouth is death’s snare [cf. 19.7a]. 8c. To the extent of your ability, be pure for your soul’s sake [see 19.4b]. 9a. Do not be one who stretches out his hands to receive but who holds them back when it comes to giving. 9b. Love as the apple of your eye all who proclaim the Lord’s word to you. 10a. Remember the day of judgment night and day, 10b. and pursue (the quest) each day108 10c. either by the word,109 by toiling and traveling in order to admonish and by taking pains to save a soul by the word, 10d. or by your hands, by working to provide a ransom for your sins. 11a. Do not hesitate to give nor grumble when you give,110 for you know who is the good paymaster the reward. 11b. Guard what you received, neither adding nor subtracting anything. 11c. Hate evil completely. 11d. Judge justly. 12a. Do not cause divisions, but make peace with disputants by bringing them together. 12b. Make confession for your sins. 12c. Do not go to prayer with an evil conscience. 12d. This is the Way of Light.111

{page 156}

II. The Way of Darkness (20.1-2)

20.1a. But the Way of the Black One is crooked and full of cursing. 1b. For it is entirely a way112 of eternal death with punishment, in which lie the things which destroy men’s souls— 1c. idolatry, arrogance, pride in power, hypocrisy, duplicity, adultery, murder, robbery, conceit, transgression, guile, malice, stubbornness, sorcery, magic, greediness. 1d. Without fear of God,113 2a. persecutors of the good; 2b. Hating truth, loving a lie; 2c. Not knowing the reward of righteousness, not associating with what is good; 2d. Not judging justly, not guarding the rights of the widow and orphan; 2e. Being alert not with respect to the fear of God, but to that which is wicked— from whom courtesy and patience are far off and distant; 2f. Loving what is worthless, pursuing reward; 2g. Not showing mercy toward the poor, not laboring on behalf of the down-trodden; 2h. Reckless with slanderous speech, not knowing him who made them; 2i. Murderers of children, corrupters of God’s creation; 2j. Turning away from the needy, afficting the oppressed; 2k. Advocates of the rich, lawless judges of the poor— 2l. sinful through and through! [cf. 21.9b]

{page 160}

Conclusion (21.1-9)

21.1a. Therefore it is fitting that when one has learned the ordinances of the Lord—as many as have been written—he walks in them. 1b. For he who does these things will be glorified in God’s kingdom; he who chooses those will perish with his works. 1c. For this reason there is resurrection, for this reason there is recompense [see 5.7]. 2. I urge 114 those who are in a high position—if you accept any of my well-intentioned advice—to make sure that there are among you those to whom you may do that which is good115. Do not fail in this. 3. The day is near in which all things will perish together with the Wicked One. The Lord is near, and his reward [see 11.8]. {page 162} 4. Once more and again I urge you; be good lawgivers among yourselves, persevere as faithful advisers to each other, remove all hypocrisy [20.1c] from among you. 5. And the God who has dominion over the whole universe will give you Wisdom, Insight, Understanding, Gnosis of his ordinances, Endurance [=2.3]. 6. Be taught by God [see 21.1a], seeking out what the Lord seeks from you; and so act that you may find (what you seek)116 in the day of judgment. 7. And if there is any remembrance of what is good, remember me as you meditate on these things, so that my earnest longing and my sleeplessness might lead to some good result. 8. I urge you, begging your favor, while the “good vessel” is still with you do not fail in any respect, but continually seek out these things and fulfill every commandment—for they are worthy. 9a. Wherefore, I hastened all the more to write whatever I could [see 1.5; 17.1].117 9b. May you be saved, children of love and peace [cf. Did. 5.2m]. 9c. The Lord of glory and of all grace be with your spirit.118


  1. So HS; but CO and L agree in reading “of (our) Lord Jesus Christ”

  2. So HL (pege); but S has “love” (agape).

  3. So H; but S (cf. L) reads “when I spoke. . . my traveling companion. . . was the Lord.”

  4. So H; but S (cf. L) reads “when I spoke. . . my traveling companion. . . was the Lord.”

  5. So H (L); but S reads “. . . Lord: Life, Faith, Hope—our beginning and end.” As is common, L is a great deal shorter here and mentions only “hope.” L could be rendered “. . . Lord: Hope of Life. . .” (cf. 1.4b, which literally reads “hope of his life”), and so might H if it were not for the punctuation marks and marginal comment in that manuscript.

  6. So H; but S has “Love which is joyfulness and a witness of the gladness. . . .”

  7. So HS; but L has “to his altar,” posibly because the verb “to draw near” can also mean “to bring an offering” (cf. 2.9).

  8. Hmg. notes here “PS. 50 [LXX] and in the Apocalypse of Adam.” On the “Adam” reference, see M. R. James, JTS 16 (1915), 409f.

  9. So S; but H (=Cl.A.) lacks “says the Lord” and reads “a day for a man to humiliate his soul” (see LXX). L has “… says the Lord, that someone should humiliate his soul without cause.”

  10. So H; but S (=Cl.A.) and LXX have “spread under you,” while L has both readings (perhaps correctly?): “put on sackcloh and strew ashes beneath you.”

  11. S adds, probably under the influence of 3.1b, “not a man humiliating his soul but….”

  12. So HS; but L (see Cl.A.) follows the usual LXX text more closely: “… and lead the homeless poor into your home. If you see somone naked, clothe him, and do not despise those of your household.” Possibly an earlier form of Barnabas did not include the final words (“nor… household”), which interrupt the stylistic balance of the passage and may have been supplied later from the better-known LXX text.

  13. So HS; but L (see Cl.A.) follows the usual LXX text more closely: “… and lead the homeless poor into your home. If you see somone naked, clothe him, and do not despise those of your household.” Possibly an earlier form of Barnabas did not include the final words (“nor… household”), which interrupt the stylistic balance of the passage and may have been supplied later from the better-known LXX text.

  14. So HS1(?); but L presupposes the similar Greek word “garments” (cf. Cl.A.), which is a widely attested varriant reading in LXX witnesses to Isa. 58.8 (see also, and correct, JBL 79 [1960], 342). S* is of no help here because of a scribal error.

  15. So S; but H and LXX have “satisfy (with food).” L lacks the entire clause.

  16. So HS; but L has “Daniel” (see 4.5), perhaps thinking of Dan. 3.13; 9.26 f.; 11.31; 12.11 (see Mark 13.14 and par.). The words “as Enoch/Daniel says” may be an early scribal gloss (Windisch, ad loc.).

  17. Hmg. comments “Apocrypha of Daniel and Esdras”

  18. So SL; but H has “kings” as in most Greek MSS of Dan. 7.24 (see 2.44)—the same problem exists in Hippolytus, Antichrist 27.

  19. So L; but HS have “kings”—note the similar problem in 4 Ezra 12.23 (cf. Dan 7.17).

  20. So HL (see Dan. 7.3; Rev. 13.1; 4 Ezra 11.1); but S has “earth” (Dan. 7.17, 23).

  21. So HL; but S adds “now” (see 4.9b).

  22. This important text is badly corrupt. The above translation follows H, with minor adjustments based on S. L is quite different: “do not be like those who heap up your sins and say that their covenant is also ours. But it is ours.” L seems to miss the point of the argument, that Christians should beware of the attitude of false security which developed in Judaism and led to the heaping up of sins.

  23. So L; but H has only “our life” and S, “your faith” (=Did. 16.2b).

  24. So H; but S lacks “therefore,” which could change the whole construction. L lacks the whole clause. Thus many editions put the verse division before the words “let us flee….”

  25. So HL (see 1 Pet. 1.2); but S has “by his blood which is sprinkled” (see Heb. 12.24).

  26. The MSS of family G begin here.

  27. So H, cf. L: “they neither believed nor loved him”; but the negative idea is lacking in S (“he preached and they dearly loved him”) and in G (“he preached and he dearly loved him [Israel]”).

  28. So HSL; but G adds “to repentance” (Luke 5.32).

  29. Or perhaps, “how could men survive when they looked at him?”

  30. So, for the most part, HS* (but it is not entirely clear where the quotation begins). L finds two quotations here: “And Isaiah [!] says, ‘by the afflicting of his body we are all healed’ [Isa 53.5b]. And another prophet: ‘I will smite the shepherd and the sheep of the fold will be dispersed.’” G mostly agrees with HS* at the start of 5.12b, but agrees with L on the form of the shepherd quotation (see Matt 26.31; Mark 14.27). S2mg. expands the S* quotation to read: “. . . then the sheep of the fold will be scattered and lost.” The verb “be lost” also could be rendered “perish” (see 5.4b; 11.7*).

  31. So HSL (see 6.6); but G has the plural “synagogues,” perhaps because the verb is plural.

  32. So SGL; but H reads “has encompassed me,” probably under the influence of LXX (see Barn 6.6).

  33. G has “whoever hopes on,” while HSL have “whoever believes in” (Isa 28.16b).

  34. So S Cl.A. (H lacks the interrogarive “what…?”); but GL have “and Moses also says to them.”

  35. The Greek is ambiguous and could be punctuated “the prophet speaks a parable of the Lord: ‘Who can…’” (see L). Cl.A., however, and probably H, understood it as above.

  36. This (awkward) comment is lacking in HL, but present in SG (cf. 5.5); L also lacks the parallel phrase in 6.12a. Possibly this is a gloss (cf. 9.3a, “these are for a witness” which L also lacks).

  37. Or, “from those whom the Lord’s spirit foresaw”. L lacks 6.14a-b.

  38. Or, “congregation,” “church.”

  39. Or, “congregation,” “church.”

  40. So HSG; but L has “of love” (see 9.7; 21.9).

  41. So HL (S adds “many things”—see 7.11; Mark 8.31, etc.); but G has “for them” (i.e., the “new people”?).

  42. The text is difficult, but apparently pictures the goat being carried (?) into the wilderness at the head of a procession (see Lev. 16.21).

  43. Apparently a thorny bush (7.11) like the blackberry. The witnesses vary somewhat as to its exact name.

  44. So GS2mg. L; but HS* lack “of the heart” [cf. 5.1].

  45. So L (cf. 9.4a; 10.12); but HSG lack “the ears of” (see 9.1c).

  46. So HSG (cf. 9.1a); but L has, perhaps correctly (see 9.4a), “your ears.”

  47. So HS; but GL add another, somewhat unique, formula—“and again, the Lord’s spirit prophesies” (cf. 12.2; see 11.5).

  48. So L; but HSG read “Do not sow” (=Jer. 4.3b LXX).

  49. The Greek witnesses here give a quotation from Deut. 10.16—“circumcise the hardness of your heart and do not stiffen your neck.” L, however, differs both in the introductory formula and in what follows: “That is, hear your Lord and circumcise the wickedness from your heart.” The last idea is echoed in several early fathers and fits the context admirably (see also Isa. 1.16; Symmachus [?] to Jer. 4.4). Possibly the entire L text should be adopted here.

  50. So L; but HS have the unparalleled formula “take it again,” while G has simply “(and) again.”

  51. Because of the repeated numbers (symbolized by letters in Greek) and abbreviations, there is a great deal of confusion among the witnesses to 9.8b—especially L, which had to attempt a translation of this cryptic section. Thus the above translation sometimes takes minor liberties with the text for the sake of the English reader (e.g., the Greek IH [= 18] is transliterated to JE).

  52. So GL; but HS have “of his covenant,” perhaps correctly (see 14.5).

  53. So HS; but GL add “by associating with” (see 10.3a, 4a).

  54. Although no serious textual problem exists here, neither the wording of this passage nor the point of the analogy is clear. The main problems are: (1) a “corrupter of children/boys” (see 19.4a; cf. 10.7a) usually means a sodomist or homosexual of some sort (so Cl. A. takes this passage), but might also mean an abortionist here; (2) the yearly increase in bodily emission probably refers to excrement, although seminal ejaculations and even birth of young are not impossible; (3) the number of “holes” could refer to anal or womb openings, or even to dens (or passages to the main den). See the commentary.

  55. Probably this means “homosexual” (cf. 10.6a; 19.4a).

  56. Although the text is in poor condition here, the meaning is fairly clear. H lacks reference to the female offenders, and L has “do not be… such a one who hears iniquity and speaks uncleanness…” (!). SG read approximately as above.

  57. So HSL (see 10.9); but G has “concerning gnosis” (cf. 1.5; 13.7). It is also possible (perhaps even preferable, since Pseudo-Barnabas tends to comment after quotations) to read this as a conclusion to 10.10—“Now your understanding is complete. . .” (so GL, which begin 10.11 with “But”), or to punctuate and render it “You are having it fully!” 11. And concerning food, Moses. . ." (see HS).

  58. So H (see G, “living fount”); but L has “fount of the water of life,” while S has “fount of life.” LXX MSS show similar variety.

  59. So HS; but G(L) reads “broken cisterns” (=LXX), and L continues as in LXX, “which cannot hold water.”

  60. So HS (i.e., as young birds learning to fly?); but G has “when their nest is stolen.”

  61. So HSL; but G strangely reads, “Then what does he say in the Son” (cf.) var. to 9.2), apparently taking the following words to refer directly to baptism—“his water is sure/faithful.” This has led some editors to begin verse 5 with this clause.

  62. So HSG; but L has “of hope and resurrection,” which in some ways fits the context better.

  63. So HS* (see Cl.A.); but GS2(?) have “he will glorify,” apparently with reference to Jesus’ resurrection.

  64. Or possibly, “… pass? The Lord says, When…” (see L).

  65. Literally “by a sign,” but the Greek allows the meaning “standard” and this is the word used in LXX Num. 21.8 f., apparently in that sense. It could also mean “by a miracle.”

  66. This entire benediction is lacking here in L, but occurs (with slight variation) in the conclusion to L at 17.2.

  67. So L; but HSG lack “Jesus.”

  68. So HSG; but L has “son of Naue,” which is contextually and historically correct, but misses the (possible) theological play on the title “Son of man.”

  69. So GS2L; but HS* lack “Messiah” and read “my Lord,” in agreement with the previous quotation. “Lord” (kyriw) here is a widely attested Greek corruption of “Cyrus” (kyrw).

  70. So HS* (see L); but GS2 have “and Son of God”!

  71. So SG; but H reads “and she did not conceive” (despite Gen. 25.21b). L lacks these words.

  72. Strangely, throughout this context S depicts Ephraim as the older, Mansse as the younger!

  73. Strangely, throughout this context S depicts Ephraim as the older, Mansse as the younger!

  74. Strangely, throughout this context S depicts Ephraim as the older, Mansse as the younger!

  75. The construction here is difficult. In view of the close parallelism between 14.1b and 13.1, and the tendency of Pseudo-Barnabas to comment at the close of a section, we have taken the affirmative particle in 14.1a (which is lacking in HL) as the conclusion to 13.7, and thus have begun the paragraph with a question. It could also be rendered “If, then, (”the people“) also was mentioned in the case of Abraham, we have received….”

  76. The construction here is difficult. In view of the close parallelism between 14.1b and 13.1, and the tendency of Pseudo-Barnabas to comment at the close of a section, we have taken the affirmative particle in 14.1a (which is lacking in HL) as the conclusion to 13.7, and thus have begun the paragraph with a question. It could also be rendered “If, then, (”the people“) also was mentioned in the case of Abraham, we have received….”

  77. The italics indicate Greek wording identical to 4.7-8.

  78. G places 14.8 after 14.5a, while HS2L have it at 14.8 and S* includes it after 14.9.

  79. So GL (cf. 16.2c); but HS read “we know.”

  80. G places 14.8 after 14.5a, while HS2L have it at 14.8 and S* includes it after 14.9.

  81. So G; but S has “to announce (news) to the poor” (see LXX) and L has “to announce (news) to men.” H lacks several words here.

  82. G places 14.8 after 14.5a, while HS2L have it at 14.8 and S* includes it after 14.9.

  83. S2mg. uniquely adds: “For David bears me witness, saying that…” and cites Ps. 90.4 verbatim as in LXX.

  84. So HS; but G(L) has “today will be a day as a thousand years.”

  85. Or, “of lawlessness” (see 4.1b, 9b; 5.3). This is the reading of L; but G has “cut short his time” (see 4.3b), and HS have “bring time to an end.”

  86. So HS*; but GS2L have “except he (who) is clean in heart,” suggesting that it is possible even “now” truly to keep the sabbath holy, or perhaps making an exception in the case of Jesus?

  87. The text is hopelessly corrupt here. H has “But if we will keep it holy. . .”; S* probably read “But if not, we will keep it holy. . .”; S2(?) possibly understood it as “See, therefore, we. . .”; G has “But if not, he keeps it holy. . .”; and L has “Seeing, therefore, that he kept it holy. . . .” If “he” is accepted (as above), it could refer to the “anyone” of 15.6b, but more probably refers to the Lord—because he will rest then, we will also.

  88. Or perhaps, “(and) that God has a house” (see 16.6-10); G has “But that. . . .” Less likely, but not imposible, would be “as if it were God’s house” or “as long as God’s house stood.”

  89. So HS; but G(L) has “Know” (see 14.7b).

  90. So G (L prefixes “and”); but HS lack this affirmation.

  91. So HGL; but S has “they and the servants”.

  92. So, possibly, G Cl.A. (L)—or perhaps, “… Name. Pay attention, in order that….” HS require the latter construction and include a conjunctive particle: “But pay attention,” or perhaps (ethically), “But walk circumspectly”.

  93. So HS* Cl.A. (G part); but S2L (G part) add “of the Lord”.

  94. So HS*L (literally “my soul hopes…”); but a longer form of this material is contained in GS2: “My (mind, and, S2) soul hopes, in accord with my desire, that I have not neglected anything of the (present, G [transposed from 17.2a]) things which are necessary to you for salvation” (cf. 1 Clem. 45.1; Did. 16.2a; Heb. 6.9).

  95. So HSL; but G lacks “present or” (see the previous footnote).

  96. L concludes at this point (lacking the Two Ways): “Again you have (understanding) concerning the majesty of Christ, how all things take place in him and through him [12.7b]—to whom be honor, power, glory, now and forever. HERE ENDS THE EPISTLE OF BARNABAS.”

  97. G lacks this phrase.

  98. H reads “who are acting wickedly.”

  99. So H, but SG place this item after 19.3d.

  100. S2mg. adds “Do not plot wickedly” (=19.3d).

  101. H includes this decalogue like commandment here (see Exod. 20.7=Deut. 5.11; Lev. 19.12), but SG place it after 19.5a.

  102. S* wrote “more than your enemy” (!) but immediately corrected it. S2 later changed it to “as yourself” (see Did. 1.2b, etc.).

  103. H lacks 19.6a entirely.

  104. Did. and Barn. use different words for “without,” and Barn. G lacks “knowing … God.”

  105. So HG (=Did.), but S has “talkative” (cf. 19.8b).

  106. Only G preserves this clause here (cf. 19.8b) as in Did.

  107. G reads “who have the same hope”

  108. G and S2mg. add “the company of the saints,” thus modifying the meaning of what precedes to agree with Did.

  109. S2mg. adds “and work and labor.”

  110. G and S2 add “Give to all who ask you” (=Did. 1.5a).

  111. S2mg. G include 19.12d, but S*H lack it.

  112. So Syr, cf. H (“for it is entirely [ηολος] of eternal death”): SG have “for it is a way [ηοδος] of eternal death.”

  113. So HGS2, but S* lacks the words “of God” (see Did. 5.2a).

  114. The material in 21.2-4(6,8) is reflected in some MSS of CO as follows: “We urge you, brethren, while there is yet time and there are among you those for whom you may work, do not fail in any respect if you have the power [cf. 21.8]. For the Day of the Lord is near in which everything will perish with the Wicked One. For the Lord is coming and his reward is with him. Be lawgivers among yourselves, be good advisers taught by God” (then 19.11b = Did. 4.13b).

  115. G (=CO) lacks “that which is good” (cf. 20.2e [Did. 5.2e]).

  116. So H (Cl. A. lacks “and so act”); but S has “that you may be found,” and G has “that you may be saved” (cf. 29.20a-b!).

  117. GS2 add “so that you might rejoice” (cf. 1.8).

  118. G adds “Amen,” after which some of its MSS read: “The epistle of the apostle Barnabas, traveling companion of the holy apostle Paul.” S has simply “Epistle of Barnabas,” while H has no subscription.